McCall Homes with Two Story w/ Below Grade Stories

Welcome to McCall, Idaho, a picturesque gem nestled in the heart of the Payette National Forest. Known for its stunning natural beauty, McCall offers a unique blend of outdoor adventure and small-town charm. With the shimmering waters of Payette Lake and the majestic backdrop of the surrounding mountains, this vibrant community is perfect for those seeking an active lifestyle or a tranquil retreat. Whether you enjoy skiing in the winter, hiking in the summer, or simply soaking in the serene atmosphere, McCall has something for everyone.

When it comes to real estate, McCall presents an array of options, including beautiful homes with two stories and below-grade stories. These thoughtfully designed residences provide ample space for families or those who love to entertain. Imagine waking up to breathtaking views and enjoying coffee on your deck, with the crisp mountain air invigorating your senses. The below-grade stories often feature versatile spaces, perfect for a cozy family room, a home gym, or an inviting guest suite—ideal for hosting friends and family who come to experience the beauty of McCall.

As you explore the market, you’ll find that these homes not only offer stunning aesthetics but also proximity to local amenities, including charming shops, delightful restaurants, and access to outdoor activities. Embrace the McCall lifestyle, where every day feels like a vacation. Discover your dream home in this enchanting city and experience the perfect blend of nature and comfort.

Newest McCall Homes with Two Story w/ Below Grade Stories

$1,899,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 3,000 SqFt. ⋅ 8.7 Acres ⋅ 98999480 MLS

Rare 8.7-acre horse property with incredible space and versatility! This 3,000 sq ft, 3-bedroom, 3-bath home features a walk-out basement, radiant floor heat, propane stove insert, and expansive 624 sq ft covered deck. A separate 1,128 sq ft ADU offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, and a 250 sq ft covered deck—perfect for guests, family, or rental income. Property also includes a 2-car detached garage and massive 4,884 sq ft steel barn. The 8.7 acres of sprinkled pasture provide an exceptional setup for horses, livestock, recreation, and rural living. On a paved driveway and parking area.

McCall

$2,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2,797 SqFt. ⋅ 0.15 Acres ⋅ 98998250 MLS

Truly one of a kind, this exceptional custom home offers an ideal location in the heart of downtown McCall with views of Payette Lake. Built with incredible attention to detail, this 2,797 square foot home features three bedrooms, each with its own bath, stunning architecture, quality finishes, and thoughtfully designed living spaces throughout. Enjoy expansive outdoor living areas on multiple levels, providing the perfect setting to take in the lake views and surrounding beauty. The lower-level bedroom offers excellent flexibility as a private studio or guest suite, complete with its own kitchen and bathroom. An extra large garage provides plenty of room for vehicles, recreational toys, and all the gear needed to enjoy the McCall lifestyle. Tucked away on a quiet street, yet just one block from Payette Lake, downtown restaurants, shopping, and entertainment, this location is truly hard to find. Currently operating as a successful vacation rental, this remarkable property offers a rare opportunity to own a distinctive home in one of McCall's most sought-after downtown locations.

520 E Lenora, McCall

$4,498,000

8 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 6,529 SqFt. ⋅ 0.51 Acres ⋅ 98996913 MLS

Nothing like this exists in McCall. Full stop. Set on .51 acres with coveted private access to Ponderosa Park and the Miles Standish Trail, this turnkey new construction is where alpine adventure meets uncompromising luxury—seconds from downtown and the marina, ten minutes to Brundage. Cross the heated driveway (winter, handled) into 6,529 square feet of pure artistry. Soaring 10' ceilings frame finishes so refined they feel curated, not chosen. Eight bedrooms—seven en suite—offer everyone their own private retreat, while two full kitchens, two bonus rooms, and a secret media room mean room to gather, host, and hide away in equal measure. The 1,020 SF garage opens through a commanding 12' door—room for the boat, the sleds, the toys, the life. Outside, a fully fenced retreat wraps around an outdoor kitchen built for golden-hour gatherings and starlit dinners. A separate ADU with private access welcomes guests in style—or works quietly as your income edge. Every inch engineered for ease. Every detail designed to impress. This isn't just a home; it's a statement, a legacy, a front-row seat to the best of McCall. Rare doesn't cover it. See it for yourself.

923 Flynn Ln, McCall

$10,800,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 4,611 SqFt. ⋅ 0.51 Acres ⋅ 98995868 MLS

Experience premier lakefront living on the shores of pristine Payette Lake in this custom mountain modern home crafted with exceptional quality. Designed by local architect Heather Susemihl of McCall Design & Planning & built by Steve Lacey in 2020 (you can visit the MDPI website to view more photos in their residential section, 15 Degrees home.) This 4611 sq ft mountain modern home features breathtaking views from almost every room. Featuring 4 bedrooms & 4 bathrooms (including the upstairs primary suite & second primary bedroom with ensuite bath) spread across multiple levels showcasing the stunning natural surroundings in thoughtfully designed spaces. This half acre property has 99’ of frontage with a private dock, sandy beach & spaces that seamlessly connect to & showcase the beauty of the lake. The private dock is where you can launch your adventures & the many carefully curated outdoor spaces offer so many opportunities to enjoy the panoramic scenery. Inside there’s not a space that wasn’t thoughtfully planned & designed to create a feeling of modern mountain living. A chef’s kitchen with high end appliances & a butler’s pantry looks out over the living/dining areas which all feature walls of windows with expansive lake views. Wood accents throughout warm up the spaces with tongue & groove ceilings, quarter sawn oak floors & walnut cabinets in this one of a kind custom home.

1882 A Warren Wagon, McCall

$10,950,000

5 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 13,232 SqFt. ⋅ 3.055 Acres ⋅ 98992745 MLS

Built for entertaining, the kitchen features stunning mirrored French door refrigerator, dual oven gas range, 2 waterfall islands and 2 glass temp-controlled wine cabinets. Indoor/outdoor kitchen is equipped with an EVO Griddle, smoker egg, built in BBQ, pot boiler, gas fireplace with 2 bifold glass walls. The living room features sliding pocket doors opening to a covered patio revealing incredible lake and mountain views. The indoor garden is self-watering with glass ceiling and grow lights. The master offers dual vanities & water closets, walk-in steam shower, jacuzzi tub and a covered patio with an auto-lifting covered hot tub. Additional features include game room, theater room, elevator, heated driveway, two 4 car oversized heated garages with Tesla Charger each w/ guest residence above garage. A heated recreational storage facility measuring 59ft X 28ft with 2 14ft pull through doors. Attached to the Recreational storage is an additional 25ft X 16ft man-cave/workshop with ½ bath. Photos may include AI-enhanced or digitally modified images.

649 Migratory Ridge Way, McCall

$625,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1,666 SqFt. ⋅ 8.58 Acres ⋅ 98989631 MLS

Multi-use acreage opportunity located on Highway 55 just south of McCall. The 8.58-acre parcel includes a 2-bedroom, 1-bath residence, two lean-tos, three-sided shop sitting on a concrete slab, a pond, and a seasonal creek. No HOA's or CCR'S! Excellent visibility and accessibility combined with flexible land-use potential make this property ideal for a variety of residential, recreational, agricultural, or investment purposes. Close to McCall amenities while offering ample space and privacy. A rare chance to secure acreage in one of Idaho's most sought-after recreation markets.

14031 Hwy 55, McCall

$1,699,999

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2,716 SqFt. ⋅ 0.54 Acres ⋅ 98989302 MLS

Rare opportunity to own a stunning log cabin retreat PLUS an adjacent lot in desirable Spring Mountain Ranch. The additional lot offers added privacy, future development potential, or the opportunity to pursue a lot split and sell separately. Tucked away on a quiet culdesac just minutes from downtown McCall, Payette Lake, and Brundage Mountain, this mountain retreat offers the perfect blend of recreation, relaxation, and investment potential. Inside, soaring ceilings, expansive windows, and warm log accents create an inviting mountain atmosphere. The open concept living area is ideal for gathering with family and friends, while large windows showcase the surrounding trees and natural beauty. After a day on the lake, slopes, or trails, relax by the fireplace or unwind in the private hot tub surrounded by peaceful forest views. Two spacious decks provide ample room for entertaining, while the 3 car garage and abundant storage make it easy to accommodate all your mountain gear. Located within Spring Mountain Ranch, owners enjoy access to premier amenities including a pool, spa, fitness center, tennis courts, clubhouse, and scenic walking paths. Whether you're searching for a full time residence, vacation getaway, or property with proven short-term rental success, this unique offering combines mountain living, income potential, and future flexibility!

1160 Bellflower Pl., McCall

$5,795,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 5,641 SqFt. ⋅ 2.06 Acres ⋅ 98988452 MLS

Immaculate Turnkey Whitetail Club Home on 2.06 Acres, perched in a breathtaking mountain setting overlooking Payette Lake & Nick Peak, this extraordinary 5641 Square foot 5 bedroom (4-ensuite & a bunk room), 6 bath, modern yet classic retreat, blends architectural sophistication with warm alpine elegance across three expansive levels. Designed with striking curved lines, dramatic steel/ metal accents & impeccable high-end finishes throughout, the home is both visually captivating & exceptionally livable. Floor-to-ceiling windows frame stunning Lake and Mountain views from almost every room while filling the interior with light, highlighting the seamless fusion of contemporary design and mountain charm. Luxurious living spaces, refined materials, and thoughtful craftsmanship create an atmosphere of understated elegance, making this one of a kind residence the ultimate mountain sanctuary for entertaining, relaxing, and year around living. Extending the living experience outdoors, the home features a covered outdoor kitchen and impressive Red Wood deck designed for unforgettable entertaining & peaceful evenings alike. In addition, an outdoor patio with fire pit and Adirondack chairs create the perfect setting for cozy nights under the stars. Beyond the extraordinary home itself, the many Whitetail Club amenities elevate ownership into a luxury, 4 Season mountain lifestyle experience.

663 Aster Court, McCall

$664,997

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1,802 SqFt. ⋅ 0.449 Acres ⋅ 98977586 MLS

Rare .44-acre Community Commercial parcel just off Main Street in McCall. This mostly updated 3 BR / 1 BA home already has the big upgrades completed, including new electrical, plumbing, siding, roof, exterior paint, and new appliances. Original hardwood floors remain under the downstairs laminate, offering instant character. An upstairs sheet-rocked room was designed for a future second bathroom and is ready for your finishing touch. Certificate of Occupancy issued. Incredible flexibility for business, mixed-use, or residential use in a prime location just minutes from Payette Lake and downtown McCall. Ideal as a second home, long-term rental, or high-demand vacation rental. Call listing agent for permitted uses and zoning link

305 N 3rd St., McCall

$2,195,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 3,208 SqFt. ⋅ 18.76 Acres ⋅ 98960061 MLS

Fabulous custom hand scribed log home on 18+ acres located between McCall and Donnelly Idaho. Approximately 10 miles to Tamarack Resort and 10 minutes to McCall. This property has a private pond and gorgeous views to the east mountains. Also has an Accessory Dwelling Unit ( ADU) attached to a very large shop/garage. Currently has a long term renter. This building is perfect for a rental, guest housing or a caretaker. The rental unit has 1300 sq ft of living space with a 1200 sq ft garage /shop. Currently furnished and can sleep 6-8. The main house has an open living area with expansive windows for views of the pond and the morning sunrise. Beautiful firepit setting next to the pond. It has a large family room and TV room with a pool table. Currently sleeps 13 in beds. One of the bedrooms is currently used as an office. Also has a large oversized garage detached from the main house with lots of extra attic storage. It has an equipment shed on the property and workshop fully equipped with woodworking tools. Also has 2 other small pole buildings for animals or storage. .Main house is currently permitted as a vacation rental. This is mountain living at its Finest. Call the listing agent for your own private tour.

43 Scheline Ct, McCall

Start Your Search

Information courtesy of Intermountain Multiple Listing Service. Information provided by IMLS is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non‐commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IMLS does not assume any liability for missing or inaccurate data. All listings provided by IMLS are marked with the official IMLS IDX icon.