New Plymouth Real Estate

Welcome to New Plymouth, Idaho, a charming and picturesque town nestled in Payette County. Known for its warm community spirit and breathtaking landscapes, New Plymouth offers a delightful blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With a population of just over 1,500 residents, this close-knit community prides itself on its friendly atmosphere and welcoming vibe.

New Plymouth is surrounded by stunning natural beauty, including the majestic Payette River and the rolling hills of the Idaho countryside. Outdoor enthusiasts will find a plethora of recreational activities at their fingertips, from hiking and biking to fishing and boating. The nearby Payette National Forest provides ample opportunities for adventure, with trails that cater to all skill levels.

The town boasts a rich agricultural heritage, reflected in its vibrant farmers’ markets and local produce. Residents enjoy fresh, farm-to-table dining experiences, with a variety of eateries that showcase the region’s culinary delights. New Plymouth also features a strong sense of community, with annual events like the Harvest Festival and Fourth of July celebrations that bring neighbors together and foster lasting friendships.

Families will appreciate the excellent educational opportunities available in New Plymouth, with dedicated schools that focus on nurturing young minds and fostering creativity. With its affordable housing options and a low cost of living, New Plymouth is an ideal place for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle without sacrificing access to essential amenities.

Whether you’re looking to settle down or simply explore, New Plymouth, Idaho, welcomes you with open arms and endless possibilities. Discover the charm of this hidden gem today!

Newest Listings in New Plymouth

$725,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1,820 SqFt. ⋅ 2.69 Acres ⋅ 99000729 MLS

Beautiful Nearly 3-Acre Property in New Plymouth – Remodeled Home, Huge Heated Shop & More! Welcome to your own piece of Idaho! This nearly 3-acre property offers a beautifully remodeled home, incredible shop space, room for animals, and a peaceful country setting—all while being just minutes from the freeway. The approximately 1,850-square-foot home features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms and has been completely remodeled inside. The home offers a huge, open living, kitchen and dining area that creates a great space for everyday living and entertaining Outside, the property really shines. The home features new board-and-batten siding with a beautiful porch. There is a huge heated shop with a lean-to on three sides. Inside the shop is a separate workshop area with its own pellet stove, making it a great setup for projects, hobbies, or additional workspace. The property also includes a large barn, fenced pasture, and animal shelter, making it ideal for anyone wanting room for animals, livestock, or additional outdoor activities. Located on a quiet dead-end road, you’ll enjoy the peaceful country atmosphere while still being conveniently located minutes from the freeway. The property is also located in a sought-after school system. This is a unique property that offers the combination of acreage, a remodeled home, outstanding shop space, animal facilities, and quiet country living.

5097 SE 1 1/2 Ave, New Plymouth

$489,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2,436 SqFt. ⋅ 0.27 Acres ⋅ 99000466 MLS

This is one of those homes that just has so much to offer! This 3 bedroom, 2 bath on .27 acres is tucked into a quiet neighborhood with a greenbelt out front and all three schools within walking distance, you’ll love the location just as much as the home itself. Inside, the chef’s kitchen features granite countertops and included appliances, with industrial LVP flooring throughout the main living areas and beautiful original wood floors in the hallway and spare bedrooms. A long list of updates has already been taken care of, including a new HVAC system, two ductless heat pumps, updated electrical throughout, new windows in most of the home, two new sliding glass doors, a new dishwasher and garbage disposal. Outside is where this property really shines! The fenced backyard has double-gate access, RV parking, flood irrigation, a paved driveway, storage shed, raspberry and blueberry plants, and an incredible 100-year-old oak tree. There’s also an oversized two-car garage, plus plumbing for a generator and RV or welding hookup. With a great backyard, tons of useful space, big-ticket updates already completed, and a location close to everything, this home is ready for its next chapter!

252 South East Boulevard, New Plymouth

$713,500

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2,060 SqFt. ⋅ 1.88 Acres ⋅ 98999772 MLS

Immaculate country home on just under 2 acres, beautifully set up and ready to enjoy. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2 bath home offers plenty of room both inside and out. The well-designed kitchen features quartz countertops and a large island/breakfast bar, perfect for gathering and entertaining. Cozy family room and living room, offers space for family to gather. Garden lovers will appreciate the 8 garden boxes with producing vegetables and berry bushes, additional planted garden space, underground irrigation and a heated 8 x10 framed greenhouse. There is also a framed 10x10 shed with a standard door and pull up door for yard equipment and tools. The impressive 42x27 three car garage features 10' door and plenty of extra storage space. Outside, enjoy a 50'x30' concrete basketball court for the kids, fenced pasture area for the animals, ample RV parking, and beautiful open views. Convenient freeway access makes commuting easy while still enjoying the space and peaceful feel of country living.

2741 Sw 3rd Ave., New Plymouth

$875,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2,261 SqFt. ⋅ 3.95 Acres ⋅ 98999054 MLS

Custom home with acreage in peaceful community with mountain views. This 3-bedroom, 2-bath 2,261 square foot home features an inviting open great room with vaulted ceilings, spacious bedrooms, a propane fireplace, abundant natural light, fully fenced/irrigated pasture, full house gas generator, and finished driveway. Hardwood floors in the main living area and master bedroom, newer carpet and LVP installed in 2023, quartz countertops throughout, as well as a whole house water filtration system. The kitchen showcases a large island, black stainless appliances, and induction cooktop stove. The master suite includes a large walk-in closet, dual vanities, and a walk-in shower. Direct access to the large covered patio and gravel area with wood burning fire pit from both the master and a secondary bedroom allows for relaxation while enjoying the views. The insulated 1,200 square foot shop includes a half bath, electric heat, water heater, washer/dryer hookups, utility sink, storage room, attached shed extension, and full RV hookups. New water heater and heat pump installed in 2022. Additional thoughtful extras include an upgraded furnace with allergen filtration system, heavy duty poly vapor barrier and insulation of interior foundation/crawlspace, and a retractable Apollo PowerScreen sunshade on the front porch.

3902 Vista Ridge Ln, New Plymouth

$620,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 3,145 SqFt. ⋅ 0.31 Acres ⋅ 98998942 MLS

Like new and impeccably designed, this 2-year-old home in New Plymouth boasts 3,145 SF of living space, featuring 6 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms. Inside, the light-filled main living area centers around a cozy built-in fireplace insert. The nearby kitchen includes a functional butler's pantry, providing extra storage, dedicated prep area, and a sleek serving space ideal for daily organization and hosting. Out back, enjoy exceptional privacy with no rear neighbors and expansive scenic views. Relax under the shelter of the covered patio, shoot hoops on your private basketball court, or unwind in the hot tub under the Idaho sky. Conveniently located near local amenities, this move-in-ready property delivers space, style, and premier outdoor living.

424 October Sky St, New Plymouth

$1,300,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 4,488 SqFt. ⋅ 3.33 Acres ⋅ 98998413 MLS

Imagine coffee on the deck, mountain views past your fence line into BLM ground — this 3.33-acre retreat is the one you've been waiting for. 5 bed | 3 bath | 4,488 sq ft main level | 3-car attached garage Walk through the front door and feel the open layout pull you in. The kitchen invites you to gather — knotty alder cabinets, granite counters, an island seating 5, & a real pantry. A wood-burning fireplace warms the great room beside it, w/ tile flooring & vaulted 13-ft ceilings. Retreat to a primary suite built for unwinding: tall ceilings, a walk-in closet, & an ensuite w/ double walk-in tile shower, claw-foot tub, dual sinks, & quartz counters. Two more bedrooms share a hall & full bath, & an oversized laundry room leads down to the 3-car garage. Downstairs is made for living: a rec room, home office, two more bedrooms (one a home gym), a full bath, a flex bonus room, & extra storage. Updates for peace of mind: 40-yr metal roof (2021), new garage doors, both upstairs baths remodeled. Outside is where memories happen — fenced yard, hot tub, mature trees, garden beds, fruit trees, a dry creek, & the firepit that's the family's favorite sunset spot. Plus a chicken coop, round corral, insulated 48x40 shop w/ pellet stove, & 2.25 irrigated pasture acres. No neighbors behind you, just open sky. HOA in place. Come see it for yourself

3820 Dundee Dr., New Plymouth

$249,999

2.5 Acres ⋅ 98998225 MLS

2.5 acres of country living with endless possibilities, including the ability to build up to 2 homes (within county restrictions)! Tucked just off Highway 30, this 2.5-acre property offers the perfect balance of convenience and country living. With plenty of room to build, grow, and create, this parcel is ready for whatever vision you have in mind. Whether you’re dreaming of a custom home, a shop, space for animals, or simply more room to spread out, this property offers the flexibility to make it happen. Bring your own builder or the owner will build to suit! Enjoy the peaceful setting while still being just minutes from town, schools, and everyday amenities. NO HOA, NO CCR, and irrigation is provided by Farmers Irrigation Company. Opportunities like this don’t come around often. If you’ve been searching for the perfect place to build your dream and enjoy the lifestyle that comes with owning acreage, this property is one you'll want to see.

TBD Highway 30 W, New Plymouth

$828,230

27.7 Acres ⋅ 98997295 MLS

Unlock exceptional versatility and long-term value with this premier 27.7-acre farm parcel in Payette County! Immediate Income Stream: Currently under an active lease with a local farmer, providing steady cash flow from day one. Turnkey Agricultural Infrastructure: Equipped with a center pivot irrigation system to support high-yield crop production. Unmatched Future Potential: Designated for future commercial zoning, offering an outstanding land-banking opportunity with significant upside potential. Prime Location & Connectivity: Conveniently located near major highway and interstate corridors, ensuring seamless logistics, equipment access, and high visibility for future development. Whether you are looking to expand your agricultural portfolio, secure steady lease income, or capitalize on high-upside commercial growth, this is the land for you. The future land use map shows commercial and subdividable to 1 acre lots, call county for specifics.

TBD SE 3rd Ave, New Plymouth

$599,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 2,664 SqFt. ⋅ 0.16 Acres ⋅ 98997187 MLS

Excellent opportunity to own a nearly new duplex built in 2023 with a strong and consistent rental history. Both units are currently occupied, offering immediate rental income. Unit A is leased through April 30, 2027, while Unit B is month-to-month, giving the new owner the flexibility to retain the current tenant or occupy the unit themselves. This is an ideal house-hacking opportunity—live in one side while rental income from the other helps offset your mortgage—or continue renting both units as a solid income-producing investment. Each spacious unit features three bedrooms and two full bathrooms upstairs, plus a convenient half bathroom on the main level. Additional highlights include quartz countertops, an attached one-car garage for each unit, and parking behind the units (RV). Tenants currently pay gas and electricity, while the owner covers water, sewer, trash, and seasonal landscaping. A well-maintained, high-value investment property with flexible ownership options and strong income potential!

116 A&B Holly Ave, New Plymouth

$855,971

14.29 Acres ⋅ 98996938 MLS

Unlock the potential of this versatile 14.29-acre commercial property situated along Highway 30 at the gateway to New Plymouth—approximately one mile from I-84. With excellent highway access and commercial zoning, the property offers exciting possibilities for RV and boat storage, self-storage, a contractor or equipment yard, warehousing, service businesses, or other commercial uses. Parcel may be subdividable to 1+ acre lots, call the county for more info. An existing home on the property could be converted into an office, administrative headquarters, or on-site manager. A commercial well is already in place, providing an abundant water source to support a wide range of commercial operations. With its generous acreage, strategic location, existing improvements, and flexible commercial potential, this is a rare opportunity to establish or expand your business in a growing and accessible area. Buyer to verify permitted uses, water capacity, and development requirements with the appropriate agencies.

4523 SE 3rd Ave, New Plymouth

$600,000

1,000 SqFt. ⋅ 0.53 Acres ⋅ 98996026 MLS

Renovated office space located on the main street New Plymouth, 2 private offices conference and meeting room. large front reception room, kitchenette, wash, dryer along with bathroom, Many possibilities for small business with great visibility Seller will consider all offers

221 & 219 N Plymouth Ave, New Plymouth

$1,140,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2,953 SqFt. ⋅ 3.345 Acres ⋅ 98995778 MLS

Welcome to a property designed with space to live, gather and grow. Set in New Plymouth, this thoughtfully updated 3-bedroom, 3-bath, 2,953-sq-ft home features spacious bedrooms, a separate 1,185-sq-ft Mother-in-Law Suite, an insulated shop, pole barn and irrigated pasture. Inside, real hardwood flooring in the main living areas, newer LVP and carpet installed in 2024, and abundant natural light create an inviting atmosphere. The kitchen is ready for everyday living and entertaining with quartz countertops, a 36-inch eight-burner range, three ovens, Bosch dishwasher, two refrigerators and instant hot water. Primary suite offers a large walk-in closet, walk-in shower, jetted soaking tub and quartz counters. A secondary bedroom features built-in shelving and direct patio access. The laundry room includes a dog-washing station and folding area. Connected by a covered breezeway, the two-bedroom,two-bath Mother-in-Law Suite includes a full kitchen and laundry hookups. Outside, enjoy a gravel courtyard with wood-burning firepit, a fully insulated 60x34 shop with two 14-foot doors, and a 1,040-sq-ft drive-through pole barn with two attached lean-tos. The pasture has HOA-managed irrigation with an automatic timer. Residents also enjoy a private community pond stocked for catch-and-release fishing and direct neighborhood access to adjoining BLM land.New roof in 2023 and water heater in 2026.

3942 Vista Ridge Ln, New Plymouth

Start Your Search

Information courtesy of Intermountain Multiple Listing Service. Information provided by IMLS is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non‐commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IMLS does not assume any liability for missing or inaccurate data. All listings provided by IMLS are marked with the official IMLS IDX icon.